Best Puppy Toys for Teething (2026)
Soothe Sore Gums & Save Your Furniture
🏆 7 Toys Tested⏱️ 10 min read🦷 Vet Approved
🦷 Puppy Teething Timeline
Understanding when teething happens helps you prepare. Peak discomfort is usually between 4-6 months when adult teeth are pushing through.
3-4 weeks
Baby teeth start coming in
5-6 weeks
All 28 baby teeth present
12-16 weeks
Baby teeth start falling out
4-6 months
Adult teeth coming in (PEAK TEETHING)
6-7 months
All 42 adult teeth present
What Makes a Good Teething Toy?
❄️
Freezable
Cold soothes sore gums
🧱
Textured
Massages gum tissue
🧴
Soft-ish
Won't damage baby teeth
👍
Right Size
Can't be swallowed
Quick Comparison
| Toy | Rating | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
KONG Puppy Toy Best Overall | ★ 4.9 | $8-12 | All puppies 8 weeks+ |
Nylabone Puppy Teething Keys Best for Variety | ★ 4.8 | $6 | Small breed puppies |
Petstages Cool Teething Stick Best Freezable | ★ 4.8 | $8 | Puppies with very sore gums |
Benebone Puppy Wishbone Best Flavor | ★ 4.7 | $12 | Flavor-motivated puppies |
Mammoth Flossy Chews Rope Best Rope Toy | ★ 4.7 | $7 | Interactive play + teething |
ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz Best Plush | ★ 4.6 | $10 | Gentle chewers who want comfort |
Nylabone Puppy Chew Starter Kit Best Value Pack | ★ 4.6 | $15 | Finding what your puppy likes |
#1 Best Overall
KONG Puppy Toy
★★★★4.9
Sizes: XS, S, M, L
FreezableStuffableBouncyDishwasher safe
✓ Pros
- • Freezable for extra relief
- • Stuff with treats
- • Softer than adult KONG
- • Very durable
✗ Cons
- • Can be too hard for tiny puppies
- • Need to supervise at first
Best For: All puppies 8 weeks+
$8-12Buy on Amazon →
#2 Best for Variety
Nylabone Puppy Teething Keys
★★★★4.8
Sizes: XS, S
Multi-texturedFlavoredLightweightAffordable
✓ Pros
- • Multiple textures
- • Bacon flavor
- • Easy to hold
- • Very affordable
✗ Cons
- • Small pieces can break off
- • Monitor chewing
Best For: Small breed puppies
#3 Best Freezable
Petstages Cool Teething Stick
★★★★4.8
Sizes: Petite, Small
FreezableTexturedWater-filledCooling
✓ Pros
- • Soak & freeze design
- • Textured nubs
- • Soft on gums
- • Helps with hot days too
✗ Cons
- • Doesn't last long frozen
- • Messy when thawing
Best For: Puppies with very sore gums
#4 Best Flavor
Benebone Puppy Wishbone
★★★★4.7
Sizes: Puppy, Small
Real flavorErgonomicDurableUSA made
✓ Pros
- • Real bacon infused
- • Easy grip shape
- • Long lasting
- • Made in USA
✗ Cons
- • Can be hard
- • Not for power chewers
Best For: Flavor-motivated puppies
#5 Best Rope Toy
Mammoth Flossy Chews Rope
★★★★4.7
Sizes: Mini, Small, Medium
Dental cleaningCottonTug toyWashable
✓ Pros
- • Cleans teeth while chewing
- • 100% cotton
- • Good for tug
- • Affordable
✗ Cons
- • Can unravel
- • Supervise play
Best For: Interactive play + teething
#6 Best Plush
ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz
★★★★4.6
Sizes: Small, Large
No stuffingSqueakySoft3-pack
✓ Pros
- • No stuffing (safer)
- • 3 squeakers
- • Soft for comfort
- • Cute designs
✗ Cons
- • Not for power chewers
- • Squeakers can be removed
Best For: Gentle chewers who want comfort
#7 Best Value Pack
Nylabone Puppy Chew Starter Kit
★★★★4.6
Sizes: Puppy
4+ toysVariety packMultiple texturesBudget friendly
✓ Pros
- • Multiple toy types
- • Great variety
- • Good value
- • Different textures
✗ Cons
- • Quality varies by piece
- • Some toys may not interest puppy
Best For: Finding what your puppy likes
💡 Teething Relief Tips
Freeze a wet washcloth
Wet, wring, freeze. The cold and texture provide instant relief.
Frozen carrots
Natural, healthy, and cold. Just watch for choking hazards.
Freeze KONG with peanut butter
Long-lasting cold relief + mental stimulation.
Rotate toys
Keep 3-4 toys out, swap weekly to maintain interest.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
How long does puppy teething last?
Most intense teething is between 3-6 months. By 7 months, all adult teeth should be in and discomfort should stop.
Is bleeding normal during teething?
Light bleeding and pink-tinged toys are normal when baby teeth fall out. Heavy bleeding warrants a vet visit.
Should I give ice cubes?
Some puppies love them! But supervise closely. Crushed ice or ice chips are safer than large cubes.